What MAKES OUR Pies So SPECIAL
Tender homemade, hand tossed crust with the perfect balance of sauce and real mozzarella. Plain is perfect. Top it if you must.
Superior ingredients set us apart. These toppings don’t show up in cans. But they do ship out in boxes.
Located on the north end of Stillwater, at the head of the Brown’s Creek Trail. Our setting is as perfect as our pies.
Located just west (about 1,178 miles, give or take) of New York, and just off the Brown’s Creek Trail in historic Stillwater, we’re the best New York pie shop in Minnesota. Our award-winning homemade, cold-fermented dough is the stuff of legend. Our secret recipe sauce is made on site every week.
Our ingredients are always fresh.
Our pies are always good.
Our town is always beautiful.
Pizza, salad, and dessert to fuel your Stillwater adventure.
The History of
Started in 2009 by New Yorker George and purchased by a long-time regular and local south hill girl in the fall of 2019. These well-loved recipes are labored over every week for the legendary crust and sauce that made a name for itself a decade ago.
Our Response to COVID-19
We continue to be open for take out only. Masks and social distancing are required for staff and customers. Picnic style courtesy tables are scattered around the building and across downtown for your use as preferred. Stay connected via Instagram or Facebook for updates.
Looking for a safe no contact take out experience? Here’s how it works:
- Order online, offer payment and select your preferred pickup time.
- Arrive at the selected pickup time.Reserved curbside parking is marked and available right outside the shop. Come to the door to pick up your order.
- Please wear a mask and maintain social distance during pick up. It’s the law. Our staff will be wearing masks and distancing as well.
- Please know the name associated with your online order. We will be waiting for you.